InfiniteDeveloper Type: Functional Issue (Minor) On all other trash cans, the items get cleared right when you put the item in there.
flashteens WON'T FIX. This is a known issue with Bukkit/Spigot/PaperMC servers, where the chest status as you see doesn't always synchronize with the actual status on server side. It can happen randomly on any chest-based trash cans in the RoFT map under multiplayer gameplay. Not just for Cheesedog Hotel. When seeing this issue happening, reopen the chest & it's expected to clear everything inside.
